Downer’s grove
Pierce Downer grew up in Plainfield, Vermont, married Lucy in Ellisburg, New York, and farmed there until his son Stephen went west to help build a lighthouse at Fort Dearborn. Pierce followed, traveled down the DuPage River and settled here in 1832. Reverend Orange Lyman and Maria Dewey Lyman arrived in 1839 and built what’s believed to be the first house in town. The first schoolhouse went up in 1844.
Abolitionist neighbors
Israel and Avis Blodgett arrived from Amherst, Massachusetts, in February 1836 and lived in a one-room log cabin while Israel worked as the blacksmith. They built their house in 1846. The family held abolitionist beliefs, and the National Park Service recognizes the house as the home of Underground Railroad conductors from 1840 to 1861.
A railroad town
The Burlington extended its line from Aurora to Chicago through Downers Grove in 1864, and the town grew around the tracks. Residents incorporated in March 1873. Some houses near the center of town still date from the middle of the 19th century, with every generation since represented on the streets around them.
Kit houses and a movie palace
Between 1908 and 1940, Sears sold kit houses by mail, and the Downers Grove Museum has confirmed 68 of them in town. On Christmas Day 1928 the Tivoli opened on Highland Avenue, and newspapers called it the “Wonder Theatre of suburban Chicago.” The Johnson family later restored it, and it still shows movies every day.
Schools and parks
According to board minutes, the old District 2 became District 58 on April 19, 1902, and a separate high school district, District 99, formed in 1923. The park district bought the land for McCollum Park in 1972 and named it for Ted McCollum, a former commissioner and volunteer firefighter who helped put the parcels together.
Keeping the stories
Lyman Woods was preserved in 1987 through a partnership of the village, the forest preserve district and the park district. The Downers Grove Museum, run by the park district at 831 Maple Avenue, finished renovating the Blodgett House and won a Best Practices Award from the Association of Midwest Museums in 2023.
Source: Downers Grove Museum · National Park Service: Blodgett House · Wikipedia: Downers Grove, Illinois · Downers Grove Park District: Sears Kit Homes · District 58: About · McCollum Park · Lyman Woods